x
Send Your Inquiry Today
Quick Quote

Your information will be kept strictly confidential.

Brushed vs Brushless DC Motor Which Is Better?

Brushed and brushless DC motors are both common types of DC drive motors. Today, drawing on our years of experience in the production and R&D of DC motors, we will provide a detailed analysis of the differences between them, covering the disadvantages and advantages of brushed vs brushless motors, control precision, efficiency, and cost. We believe that after reading this article, you will be able to quickly determine which type of drive motor is better for your project!

What is a Brushed Motor vs Brushless DC Motor

Brushed DC motors (also known as carbon brush DC motors) are the most technologically mature DC drive solutions. Low-voltage DC power sources, such as DC 12V, 24V, 36V, and 48V, typically power them. They are highly reliable, feature a simple design, and require no external controller; they begin rotating as soon as power is applied, making them easy to operate and cost-effective.

brushed DC motor

As the name implies, brushless DC motors (BLDC motors) do not use carbon brushes; instead, they achieve rotation through electronic commutation. Consequently, they offer high efficiency and low maintenance requirements. However, they must be used in conjunction with a driver to enable precise, wide-range speed control and forward/reverse operation.

BLDC motor

Brushed vs Brushless Motor: Pros and Cons

Brushed DC MotorBrushless DC Motor
AdvantageLow initial purchase costHigher-rated speed limit
Simple constructionLong service life (depending on bearing life)
Easy to operateHigh efficiency
Flexible speed control
Maintenance-free
Low noise
Compact design
Excellent heat dissipation
Extremely low electromagnetic interference (EMI)
DisadvantageCarbon brushes wear out easily, requiring frequent replacement and maintenanceComplex control
Sparking occurs easily at the contact points, resulting in arcingHigh initial purchase cost
Loud noiseDifficult to develop and debug
Lower maximum speed limit compared to brushless motors
Shorter service life
Significant electromagnetic interference (EMI)
Poor heat dissipation

Difference Between Brush and Brushless DC Motor

Working Principle

Brushed DC motor: When the coil windings on the rotor are energized, they generate a magnetic field, acting as an electromagnet. Current is supplied to the rotor through sliding contact with the commutator and carbon brushes. As the motor rotates, the direction of the current continuously changes, thereby periodically reversing the rotor’s magnetic poles and causing the rotor to rotate. At the same time, the interaction between the stator’s (permanent magnet) constant magnetic field and the rotor’s electromagnetic field (as poles repel, opposite poles attract) generates an electromagnetic torque, driving the rotor to rotate continuously.

Construction: Brushed DC motor consists of rotor, stator, winding, carbon brushes, and commutator.

Brushed vs Brushless DC Motor Internal Construction

Brushless DC Motors: In contrast to brushed DC motors, the winding coils of BLDC motors are fixed to the stator, while the rotor consists of permanent magnets. Depending on the rotor’s position relative to the windings, motors with the rotor located inside the windings are called inrunner BLDC motors, and those with the rotor located outside the windings are called outrunner BLDC motors.

The BLDC motor controller uses feedback signals from position sensors (such as Hall sensors) to determine the rotor’s real-time position and, based on this, precisely supplies current with different phases to the stator windings. By continuously varying the direction and waveform of the input current, a composite magnetic field is generated within the stator that rotates about the motor’s geometric axis. This magnetic force drives the rotor to rotate in sync, thereby converting electrical energy into mechanical energy.

Construction: Brushless DC motor consists of rotor, stator, windings, and position sensor.

Efficiency

Brushless DC motors eliminate the physical friction between carbon brushes and the commutator, as well as arc losses, and typically achieve higher efficiency, ranging from approximately 80% to 90%. In contrast, brushed DC motors are limited by mechanical losses, with efficiency typically ranging from about 60% to 75%.

Torque

Brushed DC motors deliver excellent torque at low speeds, with starting torque ranging from 1.25 to 5 times the rated torque, depending on the motor’s specific design and application requirements. They are suitable for equipment that requires frequent starts and stops. However, since brushed DC motors lack overload protection, it is generally recommended to limit overloads to approximately 2 times the rated torque to prevent premature motor failure.

The starting torque of a brushless DC motor is generally around 2 times the rated torque. However, due to limitations in sensor accuracy and physical characteristics, brushless DC motors may experience torque fluctuations or reduced torque at low speeds (0–300 rpm, depending on the driver). By using a driver equipped with a torque sensor to precisely control the current, stable torque output can be achieved across a range of operating speeds.

Speed Range

Brushed DC motors typically have a maximum rated speed of 3,000 RPM; operating them at higher speeds is not recommended, as excessive speed accelerates wear, significantly shortens the life of the carbon brushes, and causes severe electromagnetic interference.

Brushless DC motors generally have a rated speed range of 1,000 to 3,000 RPM, with a maximum speed of up to 20,000 RPM; higher rated speeds can also be customized based on specific operating conditions.

Control Method

Brushed DC motors control speed and direction by altering the polarity and magnitude of the supply voltage, making them simple to control.

Brushless DC motors require a compatible driver and support various control methods, including communication control, PWM, and 0–5V/10V analog signals, enabling wide-range speed regulation, forward and reverse operation, and precise speed control.

Precision

Brushed DC motors are relatively simple to control; speed is primarily adjusted by regulating the input voltage. However, under complex operating conditions, their dynamic response and control accuracy are limited.

Brushless DC motors can achieve more precise speed control through more sophisticated electronic control systems. If even more precise position control or constant torque output is required, the position sensor can be replaced with a high-precision encoder.

Size&Power Density

Brushless DC motors do not require physical carbon brushes or commutators; they offer higher power density. At the same rated power, brushless motors are more compact than brushed motors.

For example, under the same 60W, a brushed DC motor measures 103 millimeters in length, while a brushless DC motor measures only 81 millimeters. This represents a reduction in length of approximately 21%. For applications with limited installation space or where a lighter overall weight is required, we recommend choosing a brushless DC motor.

Brushed vs Brushless DC Motor Size Drawing

Noise

Brushed DC motors generate significant noise due to the continuous physical friction between the carbon brushes and the commutator during rotation. A single motor typically produces noise levels exceeding 70 dB and also generates electrical interference (electrical noise) caused by arcing.

In contrast, brushless DC motors eliminate friction through electronic commutation, resulting in quiet operation. Single motor typically produces noise levels below 50 dB, making them suitable for precision equipment with strict noise requirements.

Life&Durability

Brushed DC motors’ service life is limited by the physical wear of the carbon brushes, which must be replaced periodically, resulting in higher maintenance costs. Their service life is relatively short, typically 2–3 years (approximately 1,000–3,000 operating hours).

Brushless DC motors, lacking the wear associated with carbon brushes, generally have a longer service life, reaching 5 to 10 years (approximately 10,000–20,000 hours) under standard conditions, though this depends on factors such as bearing quality, frequency of use, and operating duration. By eliminating physical wear, brushless motors maintain higher control precision and consistency during long-term operation.

Heat Dissipation

In brushed DC motors, the continuous mechanical friction and electrochemical reactions between the brushes and the commutator generate contact resistance that releases a significant amount of heat, making them prone to overheating. Furthermore, since permanent magnets are heat-sensitive components, excessive temperatures can cause demagnetization, thereby reducing motor performance.

In brushless DC motors, the heat-generating windings are mounted directly on the stator and in contact with the motor housing, offering a significant advantage in heat dissipation efficiency. This makes them more suitable for industrial automation equipment requiring long-term, stable operation.

Cost

Brushed DC motors have a relatively low cost per motor; however, when factoring in maintenance costs associated with frequent brush replacement, high power losses, and the risk of repairs due to wear and tear, the total cost of ownership for brushed motors may be higher in the long run.

While brushless motors have a higher initial investment cost, their high energy efficiency, long service life, and maintenance-free operation allow them to save more on energy expenses and maintenance costs over the long term.

Application

Brushed DC motors are rarely used in non-standard applications; they are typically employed for simple rotation or low-speed, high-torque applications. Examples include inspection tools, small warehouse robots (AGVs), rail-guided shuttles (RGVs), power tools, and simple industrial machinery.

Brushless DC motors are suitable for high-speed, high-precision applications, such as model airplanes, drones, main drive motors for electric vehicles, industrial automation equipment, robots, lawn mowers, electric drills, leaf blowers, and cordless pruners. Brushless DC motors advantage of high efficiency, long service life, low noise, and maintenance-free operation, making them ideal for continuous operation and equipment with stringent performance requirements.

Conclusion

Brushed DC motors and brushless DC motors are two types of DC motors that have their own set of advantages. These motors are used in different engineering fields. As a professional manufacturer of brushless DC motors, BeUDMKE recommends prioritizing performance early in the project. This approach allows you not only optimizes long term cost, but also to make it easier to select the appropriate motion control solution.

FAQ

Can Brushless DC Motors Overheat? How to Prevent It?

Brushless DC motors can also overheat, and this is particularly likely to occur under the following conditions:

  1. Prolonged operation at full load
  2. Overloading
  3. Frequent starts and stops, as well as acceleration and deceleration
  4. Motor stalling
  5. Improperly matched driver parameters, leading to current fluctuations
  6. Excessively high ambient temperature

Prevention methods:

  1. Reduce the duration of each motor operation cycle
  2. Install temperature sensors to monitor motor temperature and set alarm thresholds or automatic shutdown thresholds
  3. Add cooling components and select an appropriate cooling method based on operating conditions, such as air cooling, water cooling, or liquid cooling
  4. Limit current by configuring rated current protection in the driver software to prevent motor overload

Looking for a reliable partner for motors and drivers in China?

Contact our engineers immediately to get the most suitable motor motion control solution for your equipment now!
Scroll to Top